### Formal definitions Prompted by [Tsuyoshi Ito's query (below)][Ito] we define <i>incomprehensible TM's</i> to be the set of all Turing Machines M that satisfy the following definition: ><b>Definition</b> Given a Turing machine M that is promised to halt for all input strings, M is called <i>incomprehensible</i> iff the following question is undecidable for at least one positive semidefinite real number $r$: >> Is M's runtime ${O}(n^r)$ with respect to input length $n$ ? That incomprehensible Turing machines exist follows concretely from [a construction by Emmanuele Viola][Viola], and broadly from the complexity-theoretic framework of Juris Hartmanis. ### Three questions Three questions are asked: > <b>Q1</b> Does the <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P_%28complexity%29#Definition">complexity class P</a> contain languages that are recognized <i>solely</i> by incomprehensible TM's? Assuming Q1 is true, we call the languages in this subset of P <i>incomprehensible languages</i>. Two natural further questions are: > <b>Q2</b> Can at least one incomprehensible language be represented concretely? <br> (if so, provide a constructive example). > <b>Q3</b> Can at least one incomprehensible TM be represented concretely? <br> (if so, provide a constructive example). To the best of my (decidedly non-expert) knowledge, these are an open questions in complexity theory … definitive references to the literature especially are desired. ---- ### Motivation The lack of an answer presently obstructs my own understanding of a broad class of problems that includes Terry Tao's [Blue-Eyed Islanders Puzzle][islanders], Dick Lipton and Ken Regan's [Urn-Choice Game][urn], and their hybridization in the context of Newcomb's Paradox via the [Balanced Advantage Newcomb Game][Newcomb]. More broadly, rigorous and/or constructive answers to these three questions would improve my appreciation of Juris Hartmanis' work in relation to proof technologies and/or decidability obstructions to settling P vs NP. [Ito]: http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/questions/11570/does-p-contain-languages-recognized-solely-by-incomprehensible-tms#comment31612_11570 [urn]: http://rjlipton.wordpress.com/2012/05/23/beyond-las-vegas-and-monte-carlo-algorithms/#comment-20525 [islanders]: http://terrytao.wordpress.com/2011/04/07/the-blue-eyed-islanders-puzzle-repost/ [Newcomb]: http://philtcs.wordpress.com/2011/12/04/class-12b-newcombs-paradox-and-free-will/#comment-539 [Viola]: http://cstheory.stackexchange.com/a/5006/1519